Difference between revisions of "Using Electoral Cycles in Police Hiring to Estimate the Effect of Police on Crime (AER 1997)"

From ReplicationWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Text replace - "Readme = 0" to "Readme = 0 - not available online")
 
(9 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 23: Line 23:
  
 
| Program code = 0 - not available online
 
| Program code = 0 - not available online
| Data= 0
+
| Data = 0 - not available online
 
| Readme = 0 - not available online
 
| Readme = 0 - not available online
 
| Method(s) & estimation = Two-stage least squares (2SLS)
 
| Method(s) & estimation = Two-stage least squares (2SLS)
 
| Data type = Micro
 
| Data type = Micro
| Data used = Uniform Crime Report from FBI from period 1970-1992
+
| Data used = FBI Uniform Crime Reports (UCR), 1970-1992
 
| Origin of data used = USA
 
| Origin of data used = USA
 
| Software used=  
 
| Software used=  
Line 46: Line 46:
 
| JEL CODES =
 
| JEL CODES =
 
| Keywords =
 
| Keywords =
| Replication type = 3
+
| Replication type = 3 - reproduction (new methods)
| Replication result [refer to replication type 1 and 2] = 4
+
| Replication result [refer to replication type 1 and 2] = 4 - partially successful
| Raw data = 1
+
| Raw data = 1 - somewhat available but insufficient to replicate final dataset
| Call into question = 1
+
| Call into question = 1 - yes
| Authors statement = 2
+
| Authors statement = 2 - used new data/method and corrected error
  
 
}}
 
}}
Line 64: Line 64:
 
| JEL CODES =
 
| JEL CODES =
 
| Keywords =
 
| Keywords =
| Replication type = 2
+
| Replication type = 2 - wide sense (new data)
| Replication result [refer to replication type 1 and 2] = 4
+
| Replication result [refer to replication type 1 and 2] = 4 - partially successful
| Raw data = 2
+
| Raw data = 2 - raw data can be used to replicate a dataset that is not substantially different from the final dataset used for the publication
 
| Call into question = 2 - partly
 
| Call into question = 2 - partly
| Authors statement = 1 - rejected results
+
| Authors statement =
 
 
 
}}
 
}}
 
|}
 
|}

Latest revision as of 16:52, 22 March 2019



This page needs attention because traffic light for raw data could not yet be set due to different values for replications.

Article

Authors Title Journal Year Edition Pages JEL Codes Keywords
Steven Levitt Using Electoral Cycles in Police Hiring to Estimate the Effect of Police on Crime AER 1997 3 270-290 k42, D72

Article information

Program code Data Readme Method(s) & estimation Data type Data used Origin of data used Software used (Version)
0 - not available online 0 - not available online 0 - not available online Two-stage least squares (2SLS) Micro FBI Uniform Crime Reports (UCR), 1970-1992 USA

Replication of this study

Authors Title Journal Year Edition Pages JEL Codes Keywords Replication type Replication result [refer to replication type 1 and 2] Raw data Call into question Authors statement
Justin McCrary Using Electoral Cycles in Police Hiring to Estimate the Effect of Police on Crime: Comment AER 2002 4 1236-1243 3 - reproduction (new methods) 4 - partially successful 1 - somewhat available but insufficient to replicate final dataset 1 - yes 2 - used new data/method and corrected error
Steven Levitt Using Electoral Cycles in Police Hiring to Estimate the Effects of Police on Crime: Reply AER 2002 4 1224-1250 2 - wide sense (new data) 4 - partially successful 2 - raw data can be used to replicate a dataset that is not substantially different from the final dataset used for the publication 2 - partly

References


DOI: IDEAS: a/aea/aecrev/v87y1997i3p270-90.html EconPapers: RePEc:aea:aecrev:v:87:y:1997:i:3:p:270-90